
North Winton Rd Location
Expand Menu
Shareable's
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Delicious sub loaf baked with buttery garlic Parmesan sauce and fresh herbs, topped with mozzarella.
$8.99
Pizza Logs
Four pizza logs served with tomato basil sauce.
$9.29+
Mozzarella Sticks
Seven battered mozzarella sticks served with tomato basil sauce.
$9.29+
Loaded Fries w/ Bacon
Loaded with mozzarella cheese, topped with cheddar cheese and bacon.
$8.99+
Bay Goodman Platter
Two loaded skins, two pizza logs, two chicken fingers, veggies, two mozzarella sticks, two sauces and sour cream.
$15.29+
10 Jumbo Wings

Served with celery and bleu cheese and choice of our authentic Buffalo sauce (mild or hot), country sweet, barbecue or garlic Parmigiano.
$12.89
1lb Boneless
Served with celery and bleu cheese and choice of our authentic Buffalo sauce (mild or hot), country sweet, barbecue or garlic Parmigiano.
$12.89+
Onion Ring Basket
$9.29
Potato Skins
$8.99
Loaded Fries
$8.99
Loaded Skins
$9.99

Classic & Specialty Pizzas
Deluxe Pizza
Our signature sauce, loaded with mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, bell peppers and Spanish onions.
$13.99+
Garlic Garden
Delicious garlic sauce and spinach, Spanish onions and fresh tomatoes over shredded mozzarella cheese.
$13.99+
Buffalo Chicken Pie Pizza
Made with our authentic Buffalo wing sauce, diced crispy chicken, topped with shredded mozzarella cheese and served with bleu cheese.
$13.99+
Three Meat Pizza
Your choice of three meat toppings, loads of freshly shredded mozzarella cheese and our classic red sauce.
$13.99+
Elite Eight Pizza
Our famous red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, ham, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions and olives.
$13.99+
Steak Out Pie Pizza
Shaved steak with sauteed bell peppers and Spanish onions with mozzarella over garlic sauce and a touch of country sweet sauce.
$13.99+
Pizza Napoli
Thin crust with olive oil, Pecorino Romano, mozzarella and ricotta, topped with fresh tomato and basil leaves.
$13.99+
Pizza Divinci
Tomato basil sauce with fresh tomato, fresh torn basil leaves, ricotta and mozzarella.
$13.99+
Pizza Sicillia
Our famous red sauce, diced onions, hot banana peppers, spicy pepperoni, Italian sausage and Pecorino Romano.
$13.99+
Veggie Weggie Pizza
Our famous red sauce with fresh mozzarella, bell peppers, mushrooms and Spanish onions top off this classic pie.
$13.99+
Our Famous Deluxe Calzone
Our signature ricotta, loaded with mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, bell peppers and Spanish onions.
$12.95+
Calzones

$9.99+
Breakfast Pizza
$13.99+

Wings & Fingers
Jumbo Wings
Jumbo Chicken Wings Served with Celery & Bleu Cheese and Your Favorite Sauce
$1.40+
Boneless Wings
Delicious Boneless Wings tossed in in Your Favorite Sauce served with Celery and Bleu Cheese Dressing
$6.99+
Chicken Fingers
Generous Order of Chicken Fingers with Tavern Fries and Your Choice of Dipping Sauce
$11.89+
Wing & Mac Snack
$10.95+
Sides
French Fries
1/2 pound of seasoned tavern fries, served with ketchup
$4.49
House Salad Side
Crisp romaine, red onions, tomatoes, red and green peppers, shaved Asiago cheese with our house dressing
$4.49
Macaroni Salad
Homemade macaroni salad with red peppers and celery.
$4.49
Home Fries
1/2 pound and cooked golden brown. Seasoned with salt and pepper.
$4.49
Caesar Salad Side
Crisp romaine, red onions, bacon and seasoned croutons, topped with shredded Asiago cheese.
$4.49
House Made Chips
Freshly made chips, seasoned with salt and pepper.
$4.49
Garlic Knot
$0.85
Garlic Knots
6 fresh knots, covered in garlic sauce. Served with fresh tomato basil sauce.
$4.49
Onion Rings
$4.49
Burgers
Rochester Burger
Topped with white American cheese, mustard, onions and our own hot sauce. Served on a hard roll, loaded with your favorite toppings. Served on our new artisan roll.
$7.95+
All American Burger
Topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and mayo. Served on a hard roll, loaded with your favorite toppings. Served on our new artisan roll.
$7.95+
Bacon Cheeseburger
Topped with bacon, American cheese, ketchup, mustard, onions and pickles. Served on a hard roll, loaded with your favorite toppings. Served on our new artisan roll.
$8.95+
My Way Burger
Topped with any or all of your favorites. Truly made your way. Served on a hard roll, loaded with your favorite toppings. Served on our new artisan roll.
$7.95+
Hamburger
Topped with any or all of your favorites. Truly made your way. Served on a hard roll, loaded with your favorite toppings. Served on our new artisan roll.
$6.49+
Spicy Chicken Breast Sandwich
$6.89+
Great Plates
Hamburger Plate
Served with 2 sides and your favorite toppings.
$13.89+
Cheeseburger Plate
Served with 2 sides and your favorite toppings.
$13.89+
Italian Sausage
$13.89+
Steak
Served with 2 sides and your favorite toppings.
$13.89+
Chicken Finger
Served with 2 sides and your favorite toppings.
$13.89+
Half Plate Chicken Finger
Served with 2 sides and your favorite toppings.
$8.49+
Half Plate Hamburger Plate
Served with 2 sides and your favorite toppings.
$8.49+
Half Plate Italian Sausage
$8.49+
Half Plate Steak
Served with 2 sides and your favorite toppings.
$8.49+

Grilled Panini
Pizano
Hot Soppressata, Tomato, Roasted Peppers, and Provelone Cheese with Our House Made Oil
$9.89+
Wise Guy
Home Made Meatballs, Cappicola, Mozzarella & Provelone Cheese Brushed with Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$9.89+
Bambino
Roasted Turkey, Bacon, Provelone Cheese Topped with Ranch Dressing
$9.89+
Margherita
Fresh Tomato & Basil with Mozzarella Cheese and Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$9.89+
The My Way
Choose from your favorite ingredients we offer to create a mouth watering sandwich
$9.89+
Salads
House Salad
Crisp romaine, red onions, tomatoes, red and green peppers, shaved Asiago cheese with our house dressing
$7.99+
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine, red onions, bacon and seasoned croutons, topped with shredded Asiago cheese.
$8.49+
Mediterranian Salad
Crisp romaine, topped with roasted red peppers, red onions, artichoke hearts, black olives and Asiago cheese.
$9.49+
Chopped Veggie Salad
Fresh mushrooms, peppers, carrots, tomatoes, red onions, broccoli and our famous original Bay & Goodman vinaigrette.
$9.49+
Bay Goodman Pizza - City
In the early 1950s Bay and Goodman opened on the corner that bares its name. One of my fondest memories are families bringing glass bowls back to the kitchen to be filled with Grandma's homemade pasta, sauce and meatballs. The popularity of her delicious sauce and Italian cooking is what lead to one of Rochester's most popular pizzerias. Not a lot has changed since then, we still use the same tomatoes and recipes today. Mangiare la vita e~ buona! "Eat, Life is Good!".98%
of 1,483 customers recommendedHours of Business
Monday and Tuesday
11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Wednesday and Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday and Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday
1:00 PM - 8:00 PM
Carryout Hours
Monday and Tuesday
11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Wednesday and Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday and Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday
1:00 PM - 8:00 PM
Delivery Hours
Monday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday and Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday
1:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Share on: